The book of evidence is the account of frederick montgomery, an irish scientist who has been imprisoned for stealing a painting and the murder of a young housemaid. Maxwellian methodology, methodological maxwellianism, and methods of historical and philosophical speculation achinstein s newtonian. The talk will be based on some parts of my recent book speculation. In this fascinating, elegantly written work, distinguished philosopher of science.
Evidence from early christian writers places the apostle john in ephesus during most of his later years c. Journal of mathematical psychology the book of evidence is a real philosophical advancea huge step forward in our ways of thinking about evidence. In 2001, achinstein published the book of evidence, a philosophical and historical study of various concepts of evidence employed in the sciences. Speculation peter achinstein oxford university press. Welcome,you are looking at books for reading, the the book of evidence, you will able to read or download in pdf or epub books and notice some of author may have lock the live reading for some of country. Peter achinstein philosophy johns hopkins university.
Discover book depositorys huge selection of peter achinstein books online. Oct 16, 2011 but, if it is evidence for anything, the said information is evidence that mary will win the lotterywhich would seem to constitute evidence against johns winning. Peter jacob achinstein, american philosopher, educator. He claims these theories are much too weak to give scientists what they wanta good reason to believeand, in some cases, they furnish.
Peter achinstein is a professor of philosophy at johns hopkins university. According to achinstein, the concept of evidence as used by scientists should primarily be seen as objective, although without excluding a subjective concept. Apart from the first chapter, which is a summary account of achinstein s ideas of evidence, the book contains two substantial chapters related to newton and one related to. Fellow american association for the advancement of science chair history and philosophy of science section l 1995. In this book achinstein introduces four concepts of evidence, which he calls potential, veridical. But, if it is evidence for anything, the said information is evidence that mary will win the lotterywhich would seem to constitute evidence against john s winning. The book of evidence oxford studies in philosophy of science 9780195171716. As the premier book in the fabulous new series oxford studies in philosophy of science, this volume is essential for philosophers of science and historians of science, as well as for statisticians, scientists with philosophical interests, and anyone curious about.
New york wikipedia citation please see wikipedias template documentation for further citation fields that may be required. Peter achinstein books list of books by author peter. In 2001, achinstein published the book of evidence, a philosophical and historical study of various. Milton and the revolutionary reader princeton university press. Restoring ambiguity to achinsteins account of evidence. Early on the first day of the week, while it was still dark, mary magdalene went to the tomb and saw that the stone had been removed from the entrance. Scientific strategies of isaac newton and james clerk maxwell.
Franklin 2001 is a very extensive historical survey of the notion of evidence, especially as it relates to a probabilistic account. Book awards book club selections books by author books by series coming soon kids books new releases teens books. In 2011, he was honored by a festschrift, philosophy of science matters. Historical essays in the philosophy of science, and more on. What is meant by scientific evidence, and how can a definition of this concept be applied in the sciences to determine whether observed facts constitute evidence that a given theory is true. In this fascinating, elegantly written work, distinguished philosopher of science peter achinstein explores this question, rejecting typical philosophical and statistical theories of evidence. Achinstein, however, does not seem to regard this derivation as essential, since he recommends his readers who want to avoid formulas and get to the bottom line p. Is there a valid experimental argument for scientific realism. Peter achinstein has presented some counterexamples which purport to show that es raising the probability of h is neither necessary nor suf. This is the first time in the book that a relatively technical derivation is presented and explained. Nov 27, 2003 although this book is primarily directed toward philosophers and historians of science, it is elegantly written and highly accessible for scientists. His previous books include concepts of science, law and explanation, the nature of explanation, particles and waves, and the book of evidence.
Achinstein introduces four concepts of evidence, defines three of them by reference to potential evidence, and characterizes the latter using a novel epistemic interpretation of probability. What is required for something to be evidence for a hypothesis the book of evidence book. John vandveld montgomery has returned to ireland in a desperate search for money. Peter achinstein has gathered some prominent philosophers and historians of science for critical and lively discussions of both general questions about the meaning of evidence and specific ones about evidence for particular scientific theories. Bringing together key primary sources spanning almost four centuries, science rules introduces readers to scientific methods that have played a prominent role in the history of scientific practice. Scientific evidence johns hopkins university press books. John 20 niv bible early on the first day of the week. A critical study by joseph mcminn gill and macmillan considers his writing up to and including the body of evidence, while mcminns the supreme fictions of john banville. Peter achinstein is a professor of philosophy at the johns hopkins university. Claiming your author page allows you to personalize the information displayed and manage publications all current information on this profile has been aggregated automatically from publisher and metadata sources. See all books authored by peter achinstein, including concepts of science. Rejects the widely held views that simplicity is a sign of truth, and that scientists should search for a theory of everything takes a pragmatic approach to the question of what scientific speculations truly are, and if they are ever legitimate or subject to restraint. The latter, which received the lakatos award, is a study of methodological problems. What mind is capable to commit an ugly, senseless crime.
Achinstein is famous for his work on evidence, explanation, and realismthe three topics with which the essays in this collection dealbut he is equally famous for his work on the history of particle mechanics. The book of evidence law and explanation similar authors to peter achinstein. This contains 20 papers on his work by former students and other important writers. In this, the first book devoted to peter achinstein s influential work in philosophy of science, twenty distinguished philosophers, including four lakatos award winners, address various aspects of achinstein s influential views on the nature of scientific evidence, scientific explanation, and scientific realism. Unfortunately, no mention or discussion about this fact is found in achinstein s book. His previous books include science rules and concepts of science, also available from johns hopkins. The book is narrated by freddie montgomery, a 38yearold scientist, who murders a servant girl during an attempt to steal a painting from a neighbour. The earliest confirmed use of 1 john was in the roman province of asia in modern turkey, where ephesus was located. In this book, peter achinstein mines the scientific work of newton and maxwell for methodological rules that can guide science when looking to formulate general laws or develop theory. In broad outline, this view claims a that confirmation is a relation of positive relevance, viz. Stathis psillos, philosophy and phenomenological research although this book is primarily directed toward philosophers and historians of science, it is elegantly written and highly accessible for scientists.
Freddie is an aimless drifter, and though he is a perceptive observer. The book of evidence peter achinstein oxford university press. The book of evidence is a 1989 novel by john banville. Achinstein is famous for his work on evidence, explanation, and real ismthe three topics with which the essays in this collection dealbut he is equally famous for his work on the history of. In this book, peter achinstein proposes and defends several objective concepts of evidence. Recent publications include the book of evidence 2001, which develops a theory of scientific evidence and applies it to cases in the history of science. Why philosophical theories of evidence are and ought to be ignored by scientists. Achinstein offers us evidence of the kind of ideological conflict that historians of the. In works such as particles and waves which won the lakatos award in 1993, the book of evidence, scientific evidence, and evidence and method, achinstein developed a standard for scientific evidence that requires the high probability of an explanatory connection between evidence and hypothesis. Along the way, he offers an extended critique of inference to the best explanation. His previous books include science rules and concepts of science, also. The book of evidence philosophy johns hopkins university.
The book of evidence by peter achinstein goodreads. Considering a wide range of writers, from john milton, thomas hobbes, john lilburne, john cleveland, and william prynne to a host of anonymous scribblers of every political stripe, achinstein shows how the unprecedented outpouring of opinion in midseventeenthcentury england created a new class of activist readers and thus helped to bring. Peter jacob achinstein born june 30, 1935, american. The book of evidence oxford university press, 2003. An extended and very opinionated study of evidence, especially as it. Peter achinstein is a professor of philosophy at johns hopkins university biography. To understand what that product is, as well as how it can be evaluated in the sciences, reference must be made to the concept of the explaining act. He specializes in philosophy of science and also has interests in the history of science.
Every page of this elegant psychopathic monologuea thief and murderers intelligent and restrained account of his inane and violent crimereveals banville to be a master of his craft. He then explores the question of whether a scientific method, such as that represented in the four rules for the study of natural philosophy that isaac newton invoked in proving his law of gravity, can be employed in demonstrating how the proposed definitions of evidence are to be applied to real scientific cases. So she came running to simon peter and the other disciple, the one jesus loved, and said, they. The book of evidence is ambitious in aim and thorough in detail.
Intro to 1 john biblica the international bible society. Evidence and method 20 discusses the scientific methods of isaac newton and james clerk maxwell. Peter achinstein books list of books by author peter achinstein. Peter achinstein specializes in philosophy of science and has interests in the history of science as well. Email citation an extended and very opinionated study of evidence, especially as it concerns probability. Irish novelist john banvilleknown to readers of mystery fiction as benjamin blackhad been writing novels for twenty years when, in 1989, the book of evidence was shortlisted for the booker. The renowned philosopher of science peter achinstein focuses on the question whether observed phenomena constitute evidence that a theory is true. Winner of irelands largest literary award for the best book of 1989, banvilles latest is an elegantly written, often darkly comic meditation upon evil and guiltand a great imaginative leap beyond his previous efforts kepler, 1983, etc. The resulting theory is then applied to philosophical and historical issues. The book of evidence is a story of a deviated mind and john banville tells his tale masterfully. In this fascinating, elegantly written work, distinguished philosopher of science peter achinstein explores this question, rejecting typical. The concept of evidence by achinstein peter ed and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at.
Subjective bayesianism is the current orthodoxy in confirmation theory. Therefore it need a free signup process to obtain the book. In mathematics, probability is defined as the ratio of the. Science rules johns hopkins university press books. This and similar considerations lead achinstein to propose a different definition of evidence. It outlines his current experiences in jail and looks back on the circumstances that led to his crime. These are situated in the context of achinstein s preferred account of evidence.
The book is clearly written, aims at a general audience and provides valuable insights into the works of these two icons of modern science. Stathis psillos, philosophy and phenomenological research although this book is primarily directed toward philosophers and historians of science, it. What is required for a fact to be evidence for a hypothesis. Achinstein proposes answers in terms of the concepts of evidence introduced. Considering a wide range of writers, from john milton, thomas hobbes, john. In this fascinating, elegantly written work, distinguished philosopher of science peter achinstein explores this question, rejecting typical philosophical and statistical. Editor peter achinstein includes works by scientists and philosophers of science to offer a new perspective on the nature of scientific reasoning. In this, the first book devoted to peter achinstein s influential work in philosophy of science, twenty distinguished philosophers, including four lakatos award winners, address various aspects of achinstein s influential views on the nature of scientific evidence, scientific explanation, and. Elsie wyatt is a born french horn player, just like her father and her grandfather before her. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Peter achinstein has gathered some prominent philosophers and historians of science for critical and lively discussions of both general questions about the meaning of evidence and specific ones about evidence for. The concept of evidence edited by peter achinstein. On his view, objective evidence has to satisfy three.
The book of evidence is a real philosophical advancea huge step forward in our ways of thinking about evidence. John banvilles novel revolves around freddie montgomery, a former scientist who becomes a murderer. A volume of his important collected essays over the years, evidence, explanation, and realism, was published in the spring of 2010. Ensure your research is discoverable on semantic scholar. Philosophical theories and applications 286 pages notes from an accidental band geek, erin dionne, sep 1, 2011, juvenile fiction, 304 pages. Stathis psillos, philosophy and phenomenological research the book of evidence is ambitious. He specializes in philosophy of science and also has interests in the history of science professor achinstein has held guggenheim, neh, and nsf fellowships, and has served as a visiting professor at mit, stanford, and the hebrew university of. Moreover, he stresses that objective evidence claims are to be understood as empirical claims and not as a priori arguments. Milton and the revolutionary reader by sharon achinstein. A major reform surge that began in the mid1980s has generated a renewed interest in fostering teacher community or collaboration as a means to counter isolation, improve teacher practice and.
Offering a new approach to scientific explanation, this book focuses initially on the explaining act itself. The first part of the book consists of five chapters which deal with. The book went through two to three stages, or editions, before reaching its current form, at the latest, around ad 80100. Freddie is an aimless drifter, and though he is a perceptive observer of himself and his surroundings, he is largely amoral. What is required for something to be evidence for a hypothesis. Although this book is primarily directed toward philosophers and historians of science, it is elegantly written and highly accessible for scientists. Ordinary language and the unordinary philosophy of peter achinstein steven gimbel and jeffrey maynes evidence, external validity, and explanatory relevance nancy cartwright maxwell, matter, and method.
1393 483 577 805 1028 1511 1168 218 1064 1274 369 391 1027 1043 1390 146 916 834 230 575 372 82 548 1342 1423 656 94 962 974 720 418 375 1395 378 133